.comment-count { float : right; width : 48px; height : 48px; background : url(D:\Sindhu Database\Blog\Bloggercommentbubble282029.png); background-repeat: no-repeat; font-size : 18px; position:absolute; margin-top : -15px; margin-right : 2px; text-align : center; }

De-Centralised V/S. Centralised Automation Wiring Architecture Comparison


1. WIRING DESIGN: 

RAKO -  DE-CENTRALISED / WIRELESS  SOLUTION

We follow #Room wise wiring infrastructure , same as normal switch board wiring. The RAKO wiring infastructure is very simple for a normal electrician to understand.
Considering its conventionally wired design, you have an #insurance & assurance that if we & RAKO fails for any reason, you can go back to standard switch board operation. The #wiring cost that you spend here is the same you are going to spend on a standard mechanical switch board
concept.

TRADITIONAL CENTRALIZED WIRED SOLUTION - WITH MOST LIGHTING AUTOMATION BRANDS IN THE MARKET

It is #Centralised wiring Architecture where by all the circuits / electrical OFF's needs to be pulled to a centralised location & communication cable to each keypads needs to be pulled. Considering the wiring infrastructure is not so simple & lengthy wires, the cabling architecture turns out to be very
expensive. In case there is problem with electrical wires, considering the length of the wire, it becomes difficult for electricians to also find the fault. Considering #"All Eggs in one basket " concept, if there is any short circuit / fire at central location, it can transmit to entire house quickly.
If you #decide to go back to basic switch board operation , you need to get rewiring done & work involved to do so is as good as making a new house. Eventually the #total cost of ownership in case of a wired system is very high considering
1) Final wiring cost considering longer wires, labour & dedication of a centralised space
2) Professional Distribution board cost, ELCB/MCB & protection circuits to
be placed in DB
3) Dependency on a professional system integrator to maintain the system as a normal electrician doesn't understand a wired system & in most cases doesn't want to even touch the back end devices as it looks very complicated to him.

2. CENTRALISED PROCESSOR: 

RAKO -  DE-CENTRALISED / WIRELESS  SOLUTION

We follow a #decentralised brain concept with no central brain / power supply concept. Each back end module is independent in terms of its memory, processing power, surge protection, Etc. & there is no dependency on a brain for its functioning

TRADITIONAL CENTRALIZED WIRED SOLUTION - WITH MOST LIGHTING AUTOMATION BRANDS IN THE MARKET

There is a #central processor that connects all the Relays, dimmers (Back end devices) to Keypads (Front end devices) & in case of its failure, the entire system will collapse & to operate your lights you need to walk to centralised locations to operate lights manually.

3. BACK END MODULE CONFIGURATION: 

RAKO -  DE-CENTRALISED / WIRELESS  SOLUTION

It's an #independent circuit design & for every circuit of dimming & On/Off, we have independent module & thus in case of a failure of one module, only one circuit of the room will get affected. Considering 3 layers of protection built into each RAKO module, chance of a RAKO module failing at site is very less.

TRADITIONAL CENTRALIZED WIRED SOLUTION - WITH MOST LIGHTING AUTOMATION BRANDS IN THE MARKET

Dimmer / Relays are in #multiple Channel Modules. For e.g., In Case Of Failure Of 1 Module Of 8 Channel Relay, all 8 Channels will not work. Thus The Entire Room Or Multiple Room Lights can get affected as 1 module channels might be shared between 1 or more rooms.

4. BUILT IN PROTECTION: 

RAKO -  DE-CENTRALISED / WIRELESS  SOLUTION

Designed based on #“BELT & BRACES” concept with 3 type of protection’s built into RAKO modules :
1) Surge protection
2) Field replaceable fuse
3) Auto thermal shutdown with our wireless decentralized design, every module is independent with its own memory, processing power & protection.

TRADITIONAL CENTRALIZED WIRED SOLUTION - WITH MOST LIGHTING AUTOMATION BRANDS IN THE MARKET

#Back end module based protection is not available & so protection needs to be taken care by Integrator at Distribution board level only. Protection is designed at input power level to the DB & not at each & every circuit level.

5. MODULAR DESIGN: 

RAKO -  DE-CENTRALISED / WIRELESS  SOLUTION

Considering the back end modules are single channel, the #system design is perfectly optimized to have exact no. of modules in your site. If there is any increase / decrease in no. of circuits, you can order the exact no. of modules.

TRADITIONAL CENTRALIZED WIRED SOLUTION - WITH MOST LIGHTING AUTOMATION BRANDS IN THE MARKET

Considering it’s a multiple channel back end module design, there can be a scenario that you need to go for 4/8 channel back end module, where you have only 1 additional circuit to be connected. There might be lot of #redudant circuits in the design.

6. SCALABILITY: 

RAKO -  DE-CENTRALISED / WIRELESS  SOLUTION

#Addition of any more circuits in same room or addition of lighting automation in another room, can be easily adapted without any wiring change. #Adding keypads to  existing room or converting an existing switch board to a RAKO automation keypad #is possible without any wiring change.

TRADITIONAL CENTRALIZED WIRED SOLUTION - WITH MOST LIGHTING AUTOMATION BRANDS IN THE MARKET

For any addition with respect to lighting circuits or professional keypads, new wiring needs to be pulled & it #becomes almost impossible to adapt to such changes once the project is at advance stages.

7. LIGHTING KEYPAD: 

RAKO -  DE-CENTRALISED / WIRELESS  SOLUTION

RAKO wide range of #wireless lighting keypads can be used or any third party switch boards / keypads can be used with RAKO interface module as front end keypads. With RAKO bed side panel, we integrate automation keypad & mechanical sockets in one switch board & there by offering one #seamless look.

TRADITIONAL CENTRALIZED WIRED SOLUTION - WITH MOST LIGHTING AUTOMATION BRANDS IN THE MARKET

Uses Proprietery Cables, Expensiive, more dependency on others, Remote offers limited functionality & not possible to have one seamless bed side panel.

8. MAINTENANCE & SUPPORT: 

RAKO -  DE-CENTRALISED / WIRELESS  SOLUTION

As it’s a room wise concept, the system can be #easily maintained by an electrician as well.

TRADITIONAL CENTRALIZED WIRED SOLUTION - WITH MOST LIGHTING AUTOMATION BRANDS IN THE MARKET

Electricians are little apprehensive about a wired system considering its complicated architecture, the system has to be maintained by a professional Installer. Your #dependency on a system integrator is very high.

9. DIMMER CUM DRIVER RANGE: 

RAKO -  DE-CENTRALISED / WIRELESS  SOLUTION

With rich knowledge of LED dimming technology, we have designed constant current & constant voltage dimmer cum driver range & thereby we can dim any LED downlighter / strip without the need to wait for a compatible driver

TRADITIONAL CENTRALIZED WIRED SOLUTION - WITH MOST LIGHTING AUTOMATION BRANDS IN THE MARKET

Dimmer cum driver range is not available & so dependency on driver compatibility is high

10. MINIMUM DIMMER LOAD: 

RAKO -  DE-CENTRALISED / WIRELESS  SOLUTION

The minimum load On a Rako dimmer is 1 watt

TRADITIONAL CENTRALIZED WIRED SOLUTION - WITH MOST LIGHTING AUTOMATION BRANDS IN THE MARKET

There is still a need for a minimum load on the adaptive phase cut dimmer

11. RGB DIMMING: 

RAKO -  DE-CENTRALISED / WIRELESS  SOLUTION

We can dim widely available RGB Lights directly   without any need to use expensive RGB lights or any other expensive dimming technology

TRADITIONAL CENTRALIZED WIRED SOLUTION - WITH MOST LIGHTING AUTOMATION BRANDS IN THE MARKET


2 comments:

Add your comment here